Pdf printmany people who know something about rosa luxemburg would be surprised to hear the name of this talk. The city of zamose was her birth place and this place was the center of jewish culture. Rosa remix represents a continuation of this everdeepening project. Luxemburg argues that trade unions, reformist political parties and the expansion of social democracywhile important to the proletariats development of class consciousnesscannot create a socialist society as eduard bernstein, among others, argued. Reform or revolu tion luxemburg strongly opposed the idea that gradually altering capitalism by way of reforms introduced through parliament could lead to socialism. Social reform or revolution, by rosa luxemburg publisher. Militant publications, london, 1986 no first published. Running through rosa luxemburg s entire work was the struggle against reformism, which narrowed down the aims of the labour movement to tinkering with capitalism instead of overthrowing it by revolutionary means. For example, we hold that she lays too much emphasis on the decline of capitalism and its collapse. Her central point had to do with the structure of globalization and the role of nationstates in a financialized economic system. Chapter v the consequences of social reformism and general nature of reformism. At the start of the 21st century the united states labour movement is at a historic low point, organized socialist politics lacks a mass working class base, and capitalism.
As rosa luxemburg, the nineteenth century jewishpolish marxist, pointed out, it matters tremendously whether we voice support for reform or revolution. Rosa luxemburg, womens liberation, and marxs philosophy. Rosa luxembourg s 1900 pamphlet reform or revolution, which critiqued reformist political strategy, has relevance to, and finds echoes in todays debates on the possibility and. Rosa luxemburg was born in the small polish town of zamosc on 5 march 1871. Oct 24, 20 reform or revolution rosa luxemburg one of the most important marxist thinkers and leaders of the twentieth century, rosa luxemburg is finding renewed interest among a new generation of activists and critics of global capitalism.
Reform or revolu tion 3 the challenge of revisionism introducing reform or revolu tion rosa luxemburg s classic pamphlet reform or revolu tion also known as social reform or revolu tion was first published in 1899. It is the basic argument about how to challenge capitalism. The struggles against reformism and against imperialist war are very much alive today. Rosa luxemburg lived in a time and place very unlike our own. Stretching, historically, from 1863 to the present, this book covers in great detail the history and developments within. Reform or revolution rosa luxemburg one of the most important marxist thinkers and leaders of the twentieth century, rosa luxemburg is finding renewed interest among a new generation of activists and critics of global capitalism. Pdf rosa luxembourgs 1900 pamphlet reform or revolution. Reform or revolution was published in the people in two weekly. Rosa luxemburg life, revolutionary activities, works. Reform or revolution and other writings by luxemburg, rosa.
Program and the polishborn marxist rosa luxemburg in sozialreform oder revolution reform or revolution, both in 1899. Reform or revolution is the more timeless of the two works, and is an interesting read even if the past 100 years does put her argument in a somewhat difficult position. As an economist and political theorist, a teacher and public speaker, a comrade and rebel, a revolutionary and martyr of. Reform or revolution and other writings dover books on history, political and social science luxemburg, rosa on. In the first chapter we aimed to show that bernsteins theory lifted the program of the socialist movement off its material base and tried to place it on an idealist base. Difference there is between reform and revolution, i shall be able, step by step, to point out. A polemic writing by the famous red rosa luxemburg, reform or revolution 1899 explains why capitalism can never overcome its internal contradictions. Rosa luxembourg article about rosa luxembourg by the free.
Luxembourg as precursor in europe of paperless office reform. Nov 07, 2014 in this video from the recent international marxist winter school 2014, marie frederiksen, editor of the danish marxist newspaper revolution, discusses the real revolutionary history, ideas, and. Rosa luxemburg work for legal reform takes place only. Accordingly, one can draw the conclusion from rosa luxemburg s argument that the time of capital, volume iii was still to come. Reform or revolution rosa luxem burg one of the most important marxist thinkers and leaders of the twentieth century, rosa luxemburg is finding renewed interest among a new generation of activists and critics of global capitalism. Reform or revolution 147 prince albert wrote next day to baron stockmar, we had our revolution yesterday, and it ended in smoke. Rosa luxemburg was a shining star of the early socialist move ment. Rosa did not grasp the national question or, rather, swatted at it, but she had a burning insight into the sources of increasing conflict. Neither a work concerned only with her marxist writings nor a personal biography concerned with her private life, this book examines rosa luxemburg s ideas on revolution and democracy and how the two are bound together by her views on the importance of political action. Until january 1912 rosa luxemburg was an orthodox follower of marx, believing that political economy had found its. They know luxemburg as the author of the brilliant pamphlets the mass strike and reform or revolution. Social reform or revolu tion from social reform or revolu tion in the first chapter we aimed to show that bernsteins theory lifted the program of the socialist movement off its material base and tried to place it on an idealist base. Reform or revolution by rosa luxemburg is a book containing a number of her most famous writings.
The accumulation of capital in southern africa rosa luxemburg. An effective refutation of revisionist interpretations of marxist doctrine, it defines the position of scientific socialism on the. Rosas ideas to the contemporary left, something we have also done by publishing, most recently, red rosa. Rosa luxemburg internet archive 1999 transcriptionmarkup. She was part of a mass labour movement with revolutionary socialist politics at its core, during a period when world socialist revolution was a tangible prospect. Rosa luxemburg reform or revolution in defence of marxism. Rosa luxemburg 5 march 1871 in zamosc, russian poland 15 january 1919 in berlin was a polish marxist politician working in both poland and germany. The war and the workers rosa luxembourg best known for her role as an economist and the author of article the war and the workers to push for the ideology of reformism.
Reform or revolu tion july 8, 2008 helen scott, editor of the essential rosa luxemburg, looks at the crucial book to take up the issue that divided the socialist movement a century ago. But this harmony endures only up to a certain point of capitalist development. View homework help rosa luxemburg theessential rosa luxemburg reform or revolution andthemassstrike. At first view the title of this work may be found surprising. She joined a revolutionary party called proletariat, founded in 1882, some 21 years before the russian social democratic party bolsheviks and mensheviks came into being. Together with lenin and trotsky she was the outstanding representative of marxism in the 20th century. Rosa luxemburg s classic pamphlet reform or revolution also known as social reform or revolution was first published in 1899. Despite the fact that this book does hold small excerpts of brilliance that encompass luxemburg s ability to combine passion with intelligence, her rebuttal was all but out of reach for me. Luxemburg, new left books, rosa luxemburgs concept of socialist democracy neither. Reform or revolution is rosa luxemburg s stark response to eduard bernsteins book evolutionary socialism. Readers of reform or revolu tion would do well to study also our penny pamphlet why capitalism will not collapse. After reading this article you will learn about the bio, life and political ideas of rosa luxemburg. Mar 01, 2020 program and the polishborn marxist rosa luxemburg in sozialreform oder revolution reform or revolution, both in 1899.
Yet only revolutionary transformation could make their victories permanent. Reform or revolution is the title of a pamphlet written by rosa luxemburg in 1900. It has become a commonplace to say that the present state is a class state. Reform or revolution and the mass strike, rosa luxemburg. Luxembourg as precursor in europe of paperless office. Rosa luxemburg puts forward certain points of view with which we do not agree. From early youth she was active in the socialist movement.
Karl kautsky, the leading theoretician of the second international, agreed with her, and revisionism consequently became a. The mass strike is part no rating as i lack the background to do so effectively. This created a frame work in which the socialist movement should push for piecemeal reform, rather than the revolutionary overthrow of the system. Luxemburg responded to bernstein in a text entitled reform or revolution. She welcomed the advent of the russian revolution, but as a revolutionary democrat, she remained vigilant, and harshly criticised the dictatorial policies of the. It was published to confront the revisionist ideology beginning to emerge in. Luxemburg was murdered in berlin during the german revolution in 1919. Reform or revolution and other writings dover books on. When capitalist development has reached a certain level, the interests of the bourgeoisie, as a class. In her pivotal 1900 polemic social reform or revolution, rosa luxemburg developed an. She was born in 1870 and on the night of january 15, 1919 she was murdered.
Luxemburg argued that those who choose reform over revolution werent looking for a calmer, more tranquil path to the same goal, but a. Of course, in the blue mists of abstract formulae, a kautsky knows very well how to trace the worldwide connections of capital which make of all modern countries a single integrated organism. What makes this edition so valuable is helen scotts superb introduction, which outlines both luxemburg. Successively, she was a member of the social democracy of the kingdom of poland and lithuania sdkpil.
Rosa luxemburg s most popular book is reform or revolution. Much of the material had appeared in article form over the. Reform or revolution 3 the challenge of revisionism introducing reform or revolution rosa luxemburgs classic pamphlet reform or revolution also known as social reform or revolution was first published in 1899. Labour legislation is enacted as much in the immediate interest of the capitalist class as in the interest of society in general. Reform or revolution, in which she defended marxist orthodoxy and the necessity of revolution, arguing that parliament was nothing more than a bourgeois sham. Jan 15, 2018 rosa luxemburg was one of the most important figures in the history of the international workers movement.
In the first place it is a thorough polemical rejection of eduard bernsteins 1899 evolutionary socialism, which book luxemburg deals with comprehensively, to the point where she concludes. Reform or revolution and other writings by rosa luxemburg. During the russian revolution of the years 1905 to 1907, rosa lux emburg. Reform or revolution by rosa luxemburg pdf rosa luxemburgs classic pamphlet reform or revolution also known as social reform or revolution was first published in 1899. After six years of preparation, a legal revolution began on february 20 in luxembourg with bill n 6543 on electronic archiving 1. Reform or revolution is not an easy read as it contains many contemporary references, though in the edition i have, donny gluckstein provides a useful introduction that puts the work in context and had many useful endnotes. Her concern about the stagnation of theoretical research in marxist political economy becomes even more urgent when we. Unlike other critics of bernsteins, luxemburg was not merely aiming to defend the status quo. The classics, part 7 rosa luxemburg, 18711919 reform or revolution. Though it was written more than 100 years ago under vastly different conditions, rosa luxemburg s pamphlet reform or revolution is. Social reform or revolu tion, by rosa luxemburg publisher. Rosa luxemburg saw the fight for social reform as a vital means of mobilizing the oppressed. While red rosas name may not be as wellknown today as the names of lenin or other male leaders, her example of revolutionary struggle is still relevant today.
The two short works by rosa luxemburg included in this volume reform or revolution and the mass strikeare both available in numerous inexpensive editions and for free online. Rosa luxemburgs funeral, frankfurt am main, germany, 1919. In the accumulation of capital, rosa luxemburg started from the aspect of capital accumulation to explore the source and internal mechanism of capitalisms crisis and make an etiological diagnosis. Verso sent me the pdf of her letters so i had a searchable. Books by rosa luxemburg author of reform or revolution. Along with a small handful of others, precious few of them theorists of any kind, rosa worked out in marxist terms the implications of capitals expansion to the very ends of the colonialized earth. Mar 25, 2009 reform or revolution luxemburg strongly opposed the idea that gradually altering capitalism by way of reforms introduced through parliament could lead to socialism. The question luxemburg addresses, though, remains important. Jul 21, 2006 reform or revolution and other writings by rosa luxemburg, 9780486447766, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. Rosa luxemburg s reform or revolution in the twentyfirst. Rosa luxemburg her analysis of imperialism and her. Along with the economists of his time he considered it outdated, both in the form expounded by british classical economists and as.
Reform or revolu tion was published in the people in two weekly. Rosa luxemburg has 159 books on goodreads with 20089 ratings. There she essentially argued that while reform and revolution were compatible, democracy and capitalism are not. Reform or revolution luxemburg pdf rosa luxemburgs classic pamphlet reform or revolution also known as. May 31, 1987 almost 70 years after the death of rosa luxemburg, her name still conjures up images of revolution and a good deal of controversy. At the time she wrote reform and revolution, luxemburg did not see the need to. Her pamphlet social reform or social revolution was published in 1900 in response to bernsteins book, the preconditions of socialism and the tasks of social democracy. In reform or revolution rosa luxemburg provided a comprehensive political response to bernstein. Why capitalism cannot overcome its internal contradictions and the working class cannot reform away exploitation and economic crises. The essential rosa luxemburg reform or revolution and the mass strike.
Following the reichstag vote of the previous day, in which the social democrats voted in favor of war credits, luxemburg cofounded the antiwar internationale group in berlin, which later evolved into the spartacus league. Southern africa is an especially important site to reconsider the dynamics of capital accumulation, given the reliance of regional businesses upon superexploitative systems such as colonialism, apartheid and neoliberalism. The accumulation of capital, probably the best book produced by a marxist and socialist thinker since karl marxs opus magnum, emerged from her sudden revelation. In attacking bernsteins reformism she was implicitly challenging the existing reformist practice of the spd leaders. Rosa luxemburg weighed in definitively at a very young age on the question of reform or revolution in this important text, and forever demolished the perspective of socialism via reform. Reform or revolu tion is rosa luxemburg s stark response to eduard bernsteins book evolutionary socialism. Rosa luxemburg simple english wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. By deconstructing bernsteins work, luxumberg reveals how reformism fails to address the inherent contradictions of capitalism in the way marx has shown. She was, after all, a major political figure and one of the. Its two most important functions are to extend production and to facilitate exchange. According to bernstein, the credit system, the perfected means of communication and the new capitalist combines are the important factors that forward the adaptation of capitalist economy.
Jul 08, 2008 rosa luxemburgs book was the first major work to take up a critical issue that divided the socialist movementand does still to this day. A graphic biography of rosa luxemburg, and more expansively, a new translation of her complete works, both in tandem with verso books. National democratic revolution, part 4b rosa luxemburg, 18711919 reform or revolution. Can we contrapose the social revolution, the transformation of the existing order, our final goal, to social reforms. In rosa luxemburg s 1899 pamphlet reform or revolution. Luxemburg writes about her opinion on whether leftist ideas could be established through democratic reform or only with a revolution. The second condition of the gradual realisation of socialism is according to bernstein, the evolution of the state in society. Reform or revolution rosa luxemburg the crisis in the german social democracy the.
1387 5 1588 393 362 62 1492 1542 258 66 1391 564 86 803 473 985 245 1272 912 872 618 343 958 454 425 430 87 1199 376 359 96 219 877 1232 1065 1048 552 195 478 1464 1388